Why Choose Cakes by Sarah?
Hi, I’m Sarah — a Sheffield-based cake maker creating beautiful, bespoke cakes for weddings, birthdays and special celebrations. I started out baking for my own children’s birthdays in our kitchen, and what began as a little hobby quickly turned into something much bigger (and sweeter).
I don’t run a bakery or a big business. It’s just me, in my home kitchen, working closely with every client to bring their ideas to life — whether that’s an elegant naked wedding cake, a colourful drip cake for a birthday, or something completely unique.
Wedding Cakes
Elegant, rustic, modern or simple. My most popular cakes at the moment are naked and semi-naked styles.
Cupcakes & Custom Orders
Perfect as gifts, favours or a little treat.
Celebration & Birthday Cakes
From milestone birthdays to themed parties and everything in between.
Let's Talk Cake
Every cake I make is completely made to order. No templates, no shortcuts — just good, honest cake that tastes as good as it looks.
If you’ve got a big day coming up, I’d love to chat about how we can make it extra special with a cake that feels truly personal.
I mainly serve Sheffield, Barnsley, and Rotherham, and can often deliver depending on your date and location.
Let’s Create Something Sweet
Ready to get started? Whether you’re planning a grand affair or a cosy gathering, Sarah is here to make your vision come to life.